LSAT Logical Reasoning Practice Test: Flaws in Reasoning
- Flaws in Reasoning
- 10 questions
- 14 minutes
Ten short arguments, each with one classic error. Tip: restate the argument in plain form (premise, then conclusion) and ask what the author has quietly skipped.
Tap an option to mark your answer. You can change your mind, or tap the same option again to leave the question blank. The correct answers and explanations appear when you finish the test.Tap an option to answer; tap it again to leave the question blank.
Your result
- 0 correct
- 0 wrong
- 0 blank
-
Question 1
In cities across the region, those with more ice cream shops have higher rates of sunburn. So ice cream shops must be causing sunburn. The reasoning is flawed because it
Correct answer: D
A correlation can come from a common cause. Sunny weather would raise both ice cream sales and sunburn, leaving no causal link between them.
-
Question 2
The senator's proposal to increase funding for public libraries should be rejected. After all, she herself was once fined for returning library books late. The argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it
Correct answer: C
Whether the senator returned books late has no bearing on whether more library funding is a good idea. This is a personal attack, not an argument against the proposal.
-
Question 3
To win the regional title, a team must win its final match. Riverside won its final match. Therefore, Riverside won the regional title. The reasoning is flawed because it
Correct answer: B
Winning the final is necessary but not sufficient. A team could win its final and still miss the title for another reason, such as an earlier loss.
-
Question 4
Every musician in the Eastgate Orchestra is a brilliant soloist, so the Eastgate Orchestra must play brilliantly as an ensemble. The argument is flawed because it
Correct answer: A
Skilled soloists can still play poorly together; ensemble playing needs coordination. The argument slides from a property of the parts to a property of the whole. The last option reverses the direction of the error.
-
Question 5
Laws are meant to be obeyed. The law of gravity is a law. Hence, gravity is meant to be obeyed. The reasoning is flawed because it
Correct answer: D
A legal rule and a physical regularity are different kinds of law; the first premise applies only to the former. This is a shift in meaning, called equivocation.
-
Question 6
A poll of 300 people leaving a gym found that 90 percent of them exercise at least three times a week. The poll shows that 90 percent of the town's residents exercise at least three times a week. The argument is flawed because it
Correct answer: B
People leaving a gym are far more likely to exercise than residents in general. The sample is biased, so the result cannot be projected on the town. Poll size is not the issue.
-
Question 7
Either the city builds the new stadium downtown or the team will leave. The city cannot afford to build downtown, so the team will leave. The reasoning is flawed because it
Correct answer: A
The argument offers only two options, but the stadium might be built elsewhere or the team might stay for other reasons. This is a false dichotomy.
-
Question 8
No one has proved that the water from the old village well is unsafe to drink. Therefore, the water from the old village well is safe to drink. The reasoning is flawed because it
Correct answer: C
Not having tested or proved a danger does not demonstrate safety. The argument treats ignorance as evidence.
-
Question 9
The editorial in today's Daily Ledger is trustworthy, because it appeared in the Daily Ledger, and the Daily Ledger can be trusted to print only trustworthy editorials. The reasoning is flawed because it
Correct answer: B
To believe the Ledger prints only trustworthy editorials, you would already have to believe that this editorial is trustworthy. The argument is circular.
-
Question 10
Every student in the class has a favorite author. Therefore, there is one particular author who is the favorite of every student in the class. The argument is flawed because it
Correct answer: D
Each student can have a different favorite. Moving from 'each has some favorite' to 'one favorite for all' is a quantifier shift.
Questions you leave blank are not counted as wrong.